Written by Toby Wilkins
On ‘Cancer of the Skull,’ Geese frontman Cameron Winter sings about “cancer of the fingers/ on the hands of a beginner.” It’s a line that suggests a young man wise and experienced beyond his years, befitting of a 24-year-old playing one of New York’s finest and most iconic venues, Carnegie Hall, whilst being recorded by Academy Award-winning director Paul Thomas Anderson. With added context, this is not too surprising – even with the wave of criticism directed at Geese’s supposed “sudden” rise (of course, anyone with a brain can see their growth as being entirely natural), there aren’t many who would deny Winter’s prodigal ability as a songwriter, proven not only on his 2024 record Heavy Metal, but also three new songs that appear on this performance’s setlist.
‘Emperor XIII in Shades’ is a stunning critique of western life’s juxtaposition with the wider world’s injustice – “It was a long day for Jesus, and a quiet night in California.” The track features perhaps his greatest vocal performance to date; it’s patient, powerful and gripping, forcing the listener to hang onto every dense line. Another new track being showcased is the heart-breaking ‘If You Turn Back Now.’ Every line hits you like a metric ton of bricks; “If you turn back now, I might just watch you go/ I might love you again if you leave me alone”; “You’re trying to hear what they’re whispering, but you don’t/ there’s a whispering that dies down wherever you go.” It’s accompanied by a piano composition so frantic that it makes your chest tight, while the major keys interspersed serve to unravel you entirely.
Winter’s reworkings of songs from Heavy Metal are subtle but fantastic. He takes a half minute break in ‘The Rolling Stones’ to play a gentle new solo that has the audience in absolute awe – you hear a loud cheer before he tumbles a little haphazardly into the next verse. Meanwhile, the breath-taking ‘Love Takes Miles,’ with a slightly jauntier composition, has times where he seems to be trying to get each line out as quickly as possible, making the track borderline formless; somehow, he stuffs “I need somebody sent down from the sun talking to me the way you used to” into a seamless second and a half. On the other hand, ‘Drinking Age’ has periods where it barely progresses at all; each line in the second section is followed by a sharp major key, and a second or two of total, gut-wrenching silence. The most significant change comes on ‘$0,’ an almost nine-minute rendition, extended from the album’s already beefy six. The vocal performance is, astonishingly, even more tragic than the original – he barely mumbles his way through some lines, repeats some more than necessary, and the ending “God is real, God is real, I’m not kidding” tangent, and the closing piano solo, is the epitome of pain. It sounds like the ramblings of an insane madman, but it’s undeniably captivating as he pours his heart out with the passion of a preacher possessed.
Ultimately, Live at Carnegie Hall is not just a project intended to hold fans over until his next studio record. It’s mesmerising, deeply emotional, and damn near better than Heavy Metal on its own merit.
